Archive | October, 2013

Disneyland Resort vs. Walt Disney World Resort Part 2: Top 8 Walt Disney World Resort Wins

17 Oct

This is Part 2 of my Disneyland Resort vs Walt Disney World Resort post.  If you missed Part 1: Top 8 Disneyland Resort Wins, you can read it here.  The same disclaimer applies.  In this post, I will discuss my Top 8 Walt Disney World Resort Wins.

Part 2: Top 8 Walt Disney World Resort Wins

1.  Isolation

As soon as you set foot on WDW property, you’re “there”.  The road signs, fire department, restaurants, gas stations, etc. all look like they belong to WDW.  The term “cast member” really does hold true in WDW in that you don’t have many chances to see backstage.  The way each park was constructed ensures that guests see attractions only from the angle they were intended to be seen.

Tower of Terror Road Sign Photo credit: flickr.com

Tower of Terror Road Sign
Photo credit: flickr.com

Reedy Creek Emergency Services Headquarters Photo credit: firehouse.com

Reedy Creek Emergency Services Headquarters
Photo credit: firehouse.com

Since most of backstage is hidden at WDW, cast members are rarely seen out of their element.  Conversely, on our most recent trip to DLR, when we were crossing Harbor Boulevard heading toward the esplanade, we saw several cast members in full costume walking to the parks to start their shift.  Seeing someone walking near McDonald’s on Harbor in a Soarin’ Over California flight attendant costume can sort of suspend the magic.

2.  Size

As Walt Disney said, they have “the blessing of size” in Florida that they never had in California. WDW is about twice the size of Manhattan.  I’m calling this a win for a few reasons.  First, it affords guests more opportunities for experiences outside of the four major theme parks.  With the resorts, golf courses, shopping, restaurants, water parks, stage shows, and outdoor activities, WDW has a lot of options for entertainment.

Aerial View of WDW Photo credit: flickr.com

Aerial View of WDW
Photo credit: flickr.com

Along with the extra land, WDW has a lot more Disney-owned resort options at varying price points.  You can stay at a value resort for a respectable rate without ever having to leave the magic.

Big Blue Pool at Disney's Art of Animation Resort Photo credit: reserveorlando.com

Big Blue Pool at Disney’s Art of Animation Resort
Photo credit: reserveorlando.com

Also, the large resort gives guests more places to escape the crowds without leaving the property.  And finally, the Walt Disney Company has plenty of land for expansion, should they choose to do so.  Although the size of the resort can be daunting when it comes to park-hopping, for the reasons above, I still consider it a win.

3.  Fastpasses

I know I already discussed that I prefer the FP system at DLR, but there is one aspect of the FP system at WDW that I like: offering FP’s for attractions with consistently long wait times.  If Disney is set on continuing the use of FP’s in all their domestic parks, there are a few rules of thumb I wish they would use when deciding where to offer them.  I would like to see a breaking point where Disney would offer FP’s for attractions that consistently exceed around a 50-minute wait.  I chose 50 minutes because I personally feel that it’s not unreasonable to ask guests to spend a total of one hour to both wait and ride a headline attraction; anything longer than that is too long for me.  When the standby queue exceeds 50 minutes, and I don’t have the option of getting a FP, I will choose to skip that attraction.

Entrance to Toy Story Midway Mania at WDW Photo credit: photosfromtheparks.blogspot.com

Entrance to Toy Story Midway Mania at WDW
Photo credit: photosfromtheparks.blogspot.com

This happened a few times with both Toy Story Midway Mania and Haunted Mansion Holiday in DLR when the queue hovered around 65 minutes during most of the day.  I wish they had offered FP’s for those attractions during that time of year.  I like that I have the option of obtaining a FP at most WDW attractions with consistently long wait times.  All of that being said, when WDW removes their standard Fastpass system in favor of Fastpass+, I’m sure I will have plenty of new recommendations for improvement.

4.  Epcot

This really isn’t a fair comparison because DLR does not have an Epcot equivalent.  But nonetheless, Epcot is a win for WDW.  It’s essentially two-parks-in-one with a year round world’s fair on one side of the park and a progress-themed area on the other side.  It’s the most mature of all US Disney Parks, and no other park challenges its uniqueness.  Epcot alone is reason enough to visit WDW if you’re a DLR veteran who is hesitant to make the trek to Florida.

Epcot's Spaceship Earth

Epcot’s Spaceship Earth

5.  Table Service Restaurants

WDW wins this category for me.  I’ve had a lot of great table service meals at DLR, but WDW has more to offer in my opinion.  WDW has at least four times as many table service restaurants to choose from, and fortunately, they have yet to homogenize the menus too terribly much (notice I said “yet”).  And not only do you have a wider variety of table service menus to choose from at WDW, you also have some really exceptional theming at many of the table service restaurants.

Magic Kingdom's Be Our Guest Restaurant Photo credit: disneyparks.com

Magic Kingdom’s Be Our Guest Restaurant
Photo credit: disneyparks.com

6.  Unique Attractions

WDW has several attractions that are unique to the east coast (Note: I apologize if I have missed any.  Some attractions have a west coast relative that provides a similar experience):

Magic Kingdom – The Magic Carpets of Aladdin, Swiss Family Treehouse, Country Bear Jamboree, The Hall of Presidents, Mickey’s PhilharMagic, Enchanted Tales with Belle, Seven Dwarfs Mine Train (opening in 2014), Monsters, Inc. Laugh Floor, Stitch’s Great Escape, Tomorrowland Transit Authority Peoplemover, Walt Disney’s Carousel of Progress, Move It! Shake It! Celebrate It! Street Party, Celebrate a Dream Come True Parade, Main Street Electrical Parade, Celebrate the Magic, Wishes, Electrical Water Pageant (on the Seven Seas Lagoon), and Mickey’s Very Merry Christmas Party.

Carousel of Progress Photo credit: disneyparks.com

Walt Disney’s Carousel of Progress
Photo credit: disneyparks.com

Epcot –  Spaceship Earth, Ellen’s Energy Adventure, Mission: SPACE, Test Track, Journey into Imagination with Figment, Living with the Land, Circle of Life: An Environmental Fable, The Seas with Nemo & Friends, IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth, World Showcase (all pavilions) including Mexico’s Gran Fiesta Tour Starring The Three Caballeros, Norway’s Maelstrom, China’s Reflections of China, Germany, Italy, The American Adventure, Japan, Morocco, France’s Impressions de France, United Kingdom, Canada’s O Canada.

France Pavilion Photo credit: disneyparks.com

France Pavilion
Photo credit: disneyparks.com

Disney’s Hollywood Studios – The Great Movie Ride, Beauty and the Beast – Live on Stage, Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular, The American Idol Experience, Streets of America, Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show, Honey, I Shrunk the Kids: Movie Set Adventure, Studio Backlot Tour, Voyage of the Little Mermaid, Walt Disney: One Man’s Dream, The Legend of Captain Jack Sparrow, Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster Starring Aerosmith, and Osborne Family Spectacle of Dancing Lights.

Casablanca Scene from the Great Movie Ride Photo credit: yorktonshortfilm.org

Casablanca Scene from the Great Movie Ride
Photo credit: yorktonshortfilm.org

Disney’s Animal Kingdom – Festival of the Lion King, Kilimanjaro Safaris, Pangani Forest Exploration Trail, Wild Africa Trek, Rafiki’s Planet Watch, Expedition Everest, Kali River Rapids, Maharajah Jungle Trek, Flights of Wonder, DINOSAUR, Finding Nemo-The Musical, Primeval Whirl, The Boneyard, TriceraTop Spin, and Mickey’s Jammin’ Jungle Parade.

Expedition Everest

Expedition Everest

7.  Attraction Comparisons

Besides the attractions that are unique to the east coast, WDW has several attractions that I believe are the better version of its sister attraction at DLR.

Under the Sea – Journey of the Little Mermaid – The exterior and queue of this attraction is much grander than The Little Mermaid – Ariel’s Undersea Adventure at DCA.  I still don’t understand why Disney chose to alter the attraction name slightly when it was installed at WDW.  No wonder guests just call it “the mermaid ride”.

Under the Sea - Journey of the Little Mermaid Photo credit: disneyeveryday.com

Under the Sea – Journey of the Little Mermaid
Photo credit: disneyeveryday.com

Splash Mountain – The attraction is slightly longer at WDW and I like the two-by-two seating configuration.

Tower of Terror – I don’t enjoy either version for motion-sickness reasons, but the exterior theming and Fifth Dimension scene in the Disney’s Hollywood Studios version give it an edge over the DCA version.

Monorail – This is not just a ride at WDW; it’s a mode of transportation.  For guests staying at the monorail resorts, it’s usually the most efficient way to travel to Magic Kingdom or Epcot.

Monorail in Epcot Photo credit: thedisneyblog.com

Monorail in Epcot
Photo credit: thedisneyblog.com

Cinderella Castle – While I do love Sleeping Beauty Castle at Disneyland Park (especially the walk-through with dioramas), Cinderella castle is much more spectacular in person.  It’s more than twice as tall as Sleeping Beauty Castle and is the focal point of Magic Kingdom Park.

Cinderella Castle Photo credit: wdwfanzone.com

Cinderella Castle
Photo credit: wdwfanzone.com

Jungle Cruise – I thought the piranhas were a nice addition to the Disneyland version, but I think the temple portion of the Magic Kingdom version gives it a leg up.

Haunted Mansion – The recent updates to this attraction with the interactive queue, the never ending staircase room, and techy hitchhiking ghosts are what make this version better than Disneyland Park’s version, in my opinion.

It’s Tough to Be a Bug – The exterior queue and location of this attraction (it’s housed inside the Tree of Life in Disney’s Animal Kingdom) are more visually interesting than DCA’s version.

Tree of Life Photo credit: examiner.com

Tree of Life
Photo credit: examiner.com

8.  Conditioned Spaces

Because of the thunderstorms and humidity during Florida’s spring and summer months, WDW has a lot more indoor seating options and air conditioned queues.  And while the outdoor seating and open queues at DLR are comfortable most of the year, it can still get very hot in Southern California.  When it does, it’s not as easy to find conditioned spaces in DLR.  There are ample conditioned spaces to retreat to in WDW.

What have I missed?  Does Walt Disney World Resort win in other areas?  Do you agree with the Top 8 Walt Disney World Wins?  Please share in the comments section!

I am not affiliated with the Walt Disney Company.  All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Advertisements

Disneyland Resort vs. Walt Disney World Resort Part 1: Top 8 Disneyland Resort Wins

7 Oct

Disclaimer:  These posts are coming from the perspective of someone who has visited Walt Disney World Resort (WDW) many times throughout her life and recently had the pleasure of experiencing Disneyland Resort (DLR) as an adult.  Although I do have many fond memories of my childhood at WDW, I’ve made many new memories at DLR that I value just as much.  I’m not attempting to “pick my favorite child”.  I simply want to share some of my own personal observations and opinions.  I adore both DLR and WDW.  All of the points in these posts are based on my experiences only.  There are undoubtedly outliers in every situation, so any time I make a general statement about either resort, please understand that I don’t believe that statement is ALWAYS true.

Here we go!

Since I believe each resort deserves its own post, I’ve split this into two parts.  In Part 1, I will discuss the “Top 8 Disneyland Resort Wins” in the battle of the resorts.  In Part 2, I will discuss the opposite: “Top 8 Walt Disney World Resort Wins”.

Part 1: Top 8 Disneyland Resort Wins

1.  Park-Hopping

This is pretty straight-forward.  With DLR having two parks and the Downtown Disney area all in close proximity of each other, park-hopping is very easy.  At WDW, you have to allow 30 to 45 minutes to park hop if you have your own vehicle or 45 to 60 minutes if you’re relying on WDW transportation.  At DLR, we’re talking a 3 minute walk (or less) from the entrance of Disneyland Park to the entrance of Disney California Adventure (DCA).  Click here for a 360 panorama from the esplanade; you can see how close the entrances are to each other.  Also, the security check is shared between both parks at DLR, so you only have to go through it once and can hop between parks freely without having to get your bag(s) checked again.  Also, because of the space restraints at DLR, the attractions are condensed to a much smaller area than WDW.  It’s much easier to experience ten headliner attractions between two parks in one day at DLR than it is to experience the same number between two or more parks at WDW.

Photo credit: disney.rocket9.net

Aerial View of Disneyland Resort
Photo credit: disney.rocket9.net

2.  Fastpasses

Although WDW does offer Fastpasses (and Fastpass+) at more attractions than DLR, I generally prefer DLR’s Fastpass system.  First, the FP’s are not “connected” between parks, so you can hold a FP in DCA and Disneyland simultaneously.  Also there are a few FP attractions that are not connected to the other FP attractions in the same park so you can hold those simultaneously, as well.  And although less available FP attractions might feel like you’re more likely to experience longer waits, it should make the standby lines shorter.  It seems counterintuitive but when an attraction offers FP, it increases the standby lines which can make it difficult to experience all the headliners without really long wait times.

DLR Fastpasses

DCA’s Fastpasses

 

3.  Nighttime Spectaculars

It’s difficult for me to discuss nighttime spectaculars objectively.  In general, I don’t tend to enjoy parades and fireworks.  I do, however, appreciate large-scale nighttime spectaculars with good production value.  The DLR version of Fantasmic is superior to the WDW version.  The only aspect of the WDW version that I enjoy more than the DLR version, is the dedicated theater with plenty of seating.  It can sometimes be difficult to find a good vantage point to view Fantasmic at DLR, but the location and sets are much more impressive at DLR.  After seeing the DLR version of Fantasmic, the WDW version seems like a less expensive imitation.  The finale scene at WDW is almost depressing with the small vessel floating by that is supposed to emulate the Mark Twain.

Disneyland's Fantasmic

Disneyland’s Fantasmic

Then there’s World of Color at Disney California Adventure.  WDW does not have its own version of this show, so DLR is the clear winner.  The closest comparison to WoC at WDW might be Illuminations: Reflections of Earth in Epcot, but they’re really not related.  Yes, Illuminations has an incredible sound track and story, but World of Color is much more exciting, in my opinion.  The technology used on the Earth Globe in Illuminations is dated and desperately needs an update; it’s difficult to see the Globe and therefore even more difficult to fully understand the story.  World of Color is simple in its story but exceptional in its execution.  The combination of projected images, music, lights, pyrotechnics, and water is what makes this show so remarkable.  It is current (for now) and appeals to all ages.

Disney California Adventure's World of Color

DCA’s World of Color

4.  Counter Service Restaurants

Altogether, I have had better experiences with the counter service restaurants at DLR than at WDW.  WDW is notorious for homogenizing menus – especially with counter service locations.  While this decreases WDW’s operational costs, it makes it a little more difficult for guests to find menu items that are special.  At DLR, the counter service restaurants offer a wider variety of menus.  And in my opinion, most of the meals they serve seem fresher and less processed.  Maybe I’ve just been lucky, but I’ve never had a bad counter service meal at DLR.  I’ve had plenty of mediocre (or even bad) counter service meals at WDW.

Turkey Breast at Flo's V8 Cafe

Turkey Breast at Flo’s V8 Cafe

Grilled Steak Skewer at Paradise Garden Grill

Grilled Steak Skewer at Paradise Garden Grill 

5.  Unique Attractions

DLR has several attractions that are unique to the west coast (Note: I apologize if I have missed any.  Some attractions have an east coast relative that provides a similar experience):

Disneyland Park – Great Moments with Mr. Lincoln, Finding Nemo Submarine Voyage, Alice in Wonderland, Casey Jr. Circus Train, Matterhorn Bobsleds, Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride, Pinocchio’s Daring Journey, Sleeping Beauty Castle Walkthrough, Snow White’s Scary Adventures, Storybook Land Canal Boats, Sailing Ship Columbia, Indiana Jones Adventure: Temple of the Forbidden Eye, Tarzan’s Treehouse, Davy Crockett’s Explorer Canoes, Big Thunder Ranch, Pirates Lair on Tom Sawyer Island, New Orleans Square (the themed area), Critter Country (the themed area), Mickey’s Toontown (the entire land) including Chip ‘n Dale’s Treehouse, Donald’s Boat, Gadget’s Go Coaster, Goofy’s Playhouse, Mickey’s House, Minnie’s House, and Roger Rabbit’s Car Toon Spin, Mickey’s Soundsational Parade, Remember Dreams Come True, and Magical.

Matterhorn Mountain and Storybook Land

Matterhorn Mountain and Storybook Land

Disney California Adventure – Red Car Trolley, a bug’s land (minus It’s Tough to Be a Bug) including Flik’s Flyers, Francis’ Ladybug Boogie, Heimlich’s Chew Chew Train, and Tuck and Roll’s Drive’Em Buggies, Disney’s Aladdin: A Musical Spectacular, Monsters, Inc. Mike & Sulley to the Rescue, Cars Land (the entire land) including Radiator Springs Racers, Mater’s Junkyard Jamboree, and Luigi’s Flying Tires, Grizzly River Run, Redwood Creek Challenge Trail, Walt Disney Imagineering Blue Sky Cellar, Paradise Pier (minus The Little Mermaid: Ariel’s Undersea Adventure and Toy Story Midway Mania) including California Screamin’, Golden Zephyr, Goofy’s Sky School, Jumpin’ Jellyfish, King Triton’s Carousel of the Sea, Mickey’s Fun Wheel, Silly Symphony Swings, Pixar Play Parade, and World of Color.

View of Cadillac Range in DCA's Cars Land

The Cadillac Mountain Range in DCA’s Cars Land 

6.  Attraction Comparisons

Besides the attractions that are unique to the west coast, DLR has several attractions that I believe are the better version of its sister attraction at WDW.

Space Mountain – The Disneyland Park version is much smoother than the Magic Kingdom version.  Also, the seats are in a two-by-two configuration, so you can enjoy the ride with a friend.

Disneyland Railroad – the Grand Canyon and Primeval World dioramas do not exist in Magic Kingdom.

Disneyland Railroad's Primeval World

Disneyland Railroad’s Primeval World 

“it’s a small world” – the façade and exterior queue are in all their original Mary Blair form.  Florida’s weather does not lend itself to many exterior queues, so the beautiful façade is hidden.  Also, the Disneyland Park version includes modern-day Disney characters in doll form.

Disneyland's "it's a small world"

Disneyland’s “it’s a small world”

Pirates of the Caribbean – The Disneyland version has more scenes, more drops, and a restaurant inside the attraction.

Buzz Lightyear Astro Blasters – You can remove your laser from the holster which is more fun than a stationary laser.

Mad Tea Party – This attraction looks gorgeous in the evening with the colorful lanterns open to the night sky.

Disneyland's Mad Tea Party

Disneyland’s Mad Tea Party 

Peter Pan’s Flight – The starry room (which doesn’t exist in the WDW version) is very pretty.

Walt Disney’s Enchanted Tiki Room – Disneyland’s version has a magical fountain in the center of the room and is Walt’s original iteration of the attraction.

Walt Disney's Enchanted Tiki Room Fountain

Walt Disney’s Enchanted Tiki Room
Magic Fountain 

7.  Weather

Overall, Southern California has much nicer and more predictable weather than Central Florida.  The annual average precipitation for Orlando is about three to four times higher than Anaheim’s annual average.  Lower humidity and less rainfall at DLR allows for more exterior queues, exposed attractions, and outdoor seating.

8.  Holiday Overlays

Because DLR is visited by many locals, the Walt Disney Company is forced to create worthwhile experiences to keep locals visiting year-round.  Space Mountain Ghost Galaxy, Haunted Mansion Holiday, and “it’s a small world” Holiday are attraction overlays that encourage locals (and out-of-town guests) to visit the resort outside of the summer months.

Space Mountain Ghost Galaxy

Space Mountain Ghost Galaxy

Haunted Mansion Holiday

Haunted Mansion Holiday

"it's a small world" Holiday Photo credit: neatorama.com

“it’s a small world” Holiday
Photo credit: neatorama.com

What have I missed?  Does Disneyland Resort win in other areas?  Do you agree with the Top 8 Disneyland Resort Wins?  Please share in the comments section!

Next week I will share Part 2: Top 8 Walt Disney World Resort Wins.

I am not affiliated with the Walt Disney Company.  All thoughts and opinions are my own.